617.584.3904
michelle(at)michellelanerealestate(dotted)com

Main Content

Chestnut Hill

Brief History

Chestnut Hill is unique in that the  zip code 02467 encompasses part of Newton, Brookline and West Roxbury.  This confuses people in terms of home values.  A home in the Chestnut Hill section of West Roxbury does not have the same value as a house in Newton or Brookline because it is part of the Boston school system. This is where having a Realtor really helps.  We know the area and can help you sort through that information. 

Originally settled by the Hammond family in the 1660s, the Newton portion of Chestnut Hill remained sparsely developed farmland well into the 1800s.  With improved rail and reservoir infrastructure in the mid to late 19th century, the area began transforming into a suburban‐estate village. The architectural fabric reflects this development era: late-19th and early-20th-century homes, designed estates, and a topography that responded to the landscape.

In 1874, the Lawrence farm land that is today the Boston College lower campus (bounded by Commonwealth Avenue, the slope dividing Boston College upper campus from lower campus, Beacon St., Chestnut Hill Driveway, and St. Thomas More Rd.) was ceded from Newton to Boston, so that Boston could add a western basin to the Chestnut Hill Reservoir. This area was excavated to become the Lawrence Basin of the Reservoir, paired with the surviving Bradlee Basin, to receive water from the Sudbury Aqueduct. Beacon St. was rerouted around the southern and western edges of the Bradlee Basin. The two halves of the Reservoir were separated to preserve the Cochituate Aqueduct, which ran under a causeway separating the two halves of the reservoir, now roughly St. Thomas More Rd. and Chestnut Hill Driveway, and a short stretch of Beacon Street.

While most of Chestnut Hill remained farmland well into the early 20th century, the area around the reservoir was developed in 1870 by landscape architect Frederick Law Olmsted, designer of Central Park in New York City and of the Emerald Necklace in Boston and Brookline.

Because of the significance of its landscape and architecture, the National Register of Historic Places designated parts of Chestnut Hill as historic districts in 1980s.  Examples of Colonial, Italianate, Shingle, Tudor Revival, and Victorian architectural styles are evident in the village’s country estates and mansions. The Boston College campus is itself an early example of Collegiate Gothic architecture.

Village Character & Lifestyle

Chestnut Hill offers a blend of refined estate-style residences, lush landscaping, and the convenience of high-end retail and local amenities. The village’s shopping corridor along Route 9 (Boylston Street) and the presence of major institutions (such as Boston College) add to its vibrancy.

Schools & Community

Chestnut Hill students attend Bowen elementary, Oak Hill Middle School and Newton South High School.  There are several private schools in nearby Brookline and a good number of Chestnut Hill students attend those schools.

Location & Commute

Located just ~6 miles west of downtown Boston, Chestnut Hill offers strong connectivity through Route 9, Beacon St and Commonwealth Ave.  There are no MBTA stations in the Newton section of Chestnut Hill but there are stops in nearby Brookline.

Parks & Sites of Interest

The nearby reservoir Hammond Pond provide green space, walking trails and scenic views.

Webster Woods on Hammond St and Kenard Park on Dudley St offer scenic acres with walking trails.

There are several high-end malls in Chestnut Hill along route 9 including  The Shops at Chestnut Hill and The Street adding convenience and prestige.

The historic home stock (Tudor, Colonial Revival, Shingle style) gives architectural character that many buyers find appealing. City of Newton

Demographics & Income

  • Median household income: around $194,398 in the Newton segment of Chestnut Hill. Average household income: ~ $279,166 (2023 estimate) in the same area.
  • Median home value: approximately $1.9 million in this village.
  • Highly educated: One source notes advanced degree attainment at ~59.5% (in the broader Chestnut Hill/Boston College area) which means you’re working in a premium market.

Housing Market & Home Ownership

  • Recent median sale price: ~ $2.25 million in the last 12 months, up significantly (e.g., ~32%) year-over-year in some metrics.
  • More extreme pricing at the high end: single-family homes often list in the multi-million-dollar range (e.g., one listing at ~$5.1 million).
  • The market is competitive: good condition, location, and presentation matter very much.

What This Means for Buyers & Sellers

For Buyers:

  • You’re buying into one of Newton’s top-tier villages — expect premium pricing but also excellent fundamentals (schools, location, lifestyle).
  • Be ready to act: good homes won’t sit long, and condition/lot/amenities will drive value.
  • Trade-offs may include smaller lots than ultra-rural suburbia, or older homes that require maintenance/update.

For Sellers:

  • You’re in a strong position: highlight prestige, walkability, amenities, green space and architectural character.
  • Presentation is vital: landscaping, curb-appeal, modern systems, and showing historic charm but updated living matter.
  • Pricing should recognize high value but also differentiate by condition, lot size and uniqueness — a cookie-cutter home will still command high price but may not outperform a well-presented estate.

In Summary

Chestnut Hill is a refined, high-demand village that combines estate-scale living, stellar location, strong schools and walking amenities. For buyers and sellers alike, the story is one of luxury-suburb meets convenience. Your role as a broker is to articulate the “why choose Chestnut Hill” (prestige, location, character) and to ensure realistic expectations around premium pricing and condition.

Related Links


This content is currently unavailable. Please check back later or contact the site's support team for more information.
Share this Page